Loading blog content, please wait...
By ActivityPay
Credit card processing fees eat into your margins on every booking. For adventure operators running zip line tours, white water rafting trips, or multi-day expeditions, those 2.5-3.5% fees add up fast. On a $5,000 group booking, you're losing $125-$175 just to accept payment.
You have two legal ways to offset these costs: dual pricing and surcharging. They sound similar, but they work differently, face different regulations, and create very different experiences for your guests. Understanding which approach fits your operation—or whether to use either at all—depends on your booking patterns, average transaction sizes, and how your guests prefer to pay.
Let's break down what each option actually means for your business and your customers.
Dual pricing means you advertise two prices for the same experience: a cash price and a card price. The cash price is your base rate. The card price is higher—typically 3-4% more—to cover processing costs.
Here's what this looks like in practice: Your scenic helicopter tour costs $300 cash or $312 by card. Both prices appear on your website, in your booking system, and when guests call to reserve. There's no surprise at checkout because customers know the pricing structure upfront.
The key advantage: dual pricing isn't considered a surcharge under card network rules, so you face fewer restrictions. You can apply it to debit cards and credit cards equally. You don't need special signage or register programming beyond displaying both prices clearly.
The challenge: managing two price points across all your marketing materials, booking channels, and communication. Your website needs both prices. Your guides need to know both prices. Your third-party booking platforms need to display both options. This creates operational complexity, especially if you offer dozens of different tours and packages.
Dual pricing works best when you have significant walk-up or phone bookings where payment method varies. If 30-40% of your customers pay cash or prefer it, dual pricing lets you reward that preference while still accepting cards without absorbing the cost.
It's also effective for high-ticket experiences. On a $2,000 multi-day rafting expedition, a $60-80 difference between cash and card pricing is meaningful to you as the operator but proportionally small enough that guests who want the convenience of card payment won't balk.
However, dual pricing requires customer education. You'll field questions about why prices differ. Your booking staff needs to explain it clearly and consistently. If you operate in a market where dual pricing is uncommon, expect some confusion initially.
Surcharging means you advertise one base price, then add a percentage fee at checkout specifically for credit card payments. Your $300 helicopter tour is listed at $300 everywhere, but when customers pay with a credit card, they see an additional $9 surcharge (3%) added to their total.
This approach keeps your advertised pricing simple and consistent across all marketing channels. Your website shows one price. Your brochures show one price. There's no confusion about what the tour costs until payment method comes into play.
But surcharging comes with strict rules. You cannot surcharge debit cards—only credit cards. You must register with card networks before implementing surcharges. Your receipts must show the surcharge as a separate line item. You need clear signage where you accept payment, both online and in person.
The surcharge cannot exceed your actual processing cost or 4%, whichever is lower. If your processor charges 2.8%, you can surcharge up to 2.8%. You can't use surcharging as a profit center.
Surcharging laws vary significantly by state. Some states previously banned surcharging outright, though many of those bans have been challenged or overturned. Before implementing surcharges, verify your state allows them and understand any specific disclosure requirements.
Connecticut and Massachusetts have particularly strict rules around surcharge disclosure. Colorado requires specific language in surcharge notifications. If you operate tours in multiple states or serve customers from various locations, compliance gets complicated quickly.
Card network rules also matter. Visa and Mastercard require 30-day advance notice before you start surcharging. You must notify your processor, who then notifies the card networks. This isn't something you can implement overnight.
Here's what many operators overlook: how your pricing approach affects the booking experience and customer perception.
With dual pricing, customers make a choice before they ever reach checkout. They see both options, consider which works for them, and proceed. The decision feels neutral—cash versus card is simply a payment preference, like choosing between two tour times.
Surcharging creates a different dynamic. Customers see your tour price, decide to book, enter their payment details, and then encounter an additional fee. Even though you've disclosed it properly with signage and terms, it still feels like something was added at the last moment. For some customers, this registers as unexpected.
Consider your average transaction size. On smaller bookings—say, a $75 kayak rental—a $2.25 surcharge might generate more negative reaction than it's worth. Customers notice small fees on small purchases more acutely. On that same $2,000 rafting expedition, a $60 surcharge is more proportionally acceptable.
Both approaches can affect booking completion rates, but in different ways. Dual pricing may reduce sticker shock at checkout since customers already chose their price point. However, displaying a higher card price upfront might make your tours appear more expensive when customers comparison shop.
Surcharging keeps your advertised prices competitive but may cause some cart abandonment when the fee appears at checkout. The key is transparency. Customers who understand why the fee exists are more likely to accept it than those who feel blindsided.
Test and track your results. Monitor booking completion rates before and after implementation. Watch for patterns—do certain tour types or price points see more abandonment? Are customers reaching out with questions or complaints? This data tells you whether your chosen approach works for your specific audience.
If you decide dual pricing or surcharging makes sense for your operation, implementation requires planning and coordination across your entire booking ecosystem.
For Dual Pricing:
For Surcharging:
Before implementing either approach, consider whether absorbing processing fees makes more strategic sense for your business model.
If you run high-margin experiences with strong repeat business and referrals, the goodwill from frictionless pricing might outweigh the processing costs. Premium adventure operators often build fees into their base pricing rather than itemizing them because it aligns with the high-end experience they're selling.
If you're competing heavily on price, adding visible fees—whether through dual pricing or surcharging—might make your tours appear more expensive than competitors who've simply incorporated costs into their rates.
Calculate what processing fees actually cost you annually, then weigh that against potential impacts on booking rates, customer satisfaction, and operational complexity. Sometimes the simplest approach is the most profitable.
Choose dual pricing if you handle significant cash payments, operate high-ticket experiences, and can manage multiple price points across your systems. It offers the most flexibility and fewer regulatory complications.
Choose surcharging if you want consistent advertised pricing, process primarily credit card payments, and operate in states with clear surcharging rules. Just be prepared for the compliance requirements and potential customer questions.
Choose to absorb costs if you prioritize booking conversion, run premium experiences, or determine that processing fees—while real—are manageable within your margins and worth the simplified customer experience.
Whichever route you take, the decision should align with your brand positioning, customer expectations, and operational capabilities. The right answer isn't universal—it's specific to how your adventure business operates and where you're headed.
Dual pricing displays two prices upfront (cash and card rates), while surcharging shows one base price and adds a fee at checkout for credit card payments. Dual pricing lets customers choose before booking, whereas surcharging adds the fee during payment processing.
No, you cannot surcharge debit cards—only credit cards can be surcharged under card network rules. Dual pricing, however, can be applied to both debit and credit card payments equally.
Yes, Visa and Mastercard require 30-day advance notice before you start surcharging. You must notify your payment processor, who then notifies the card networks, and you need to verify surcharging is legal in your state.
The surcharge cannot exceed your actual processing cost or 4%, whichever is lower. If your processor charges 2.8%, you can only surcharge up to 2.8%—you cannot use surcharging as a profit center.
Not necessarily—absorbing processing fees might be better if you run premium experiences or compete heavily on price. The right choice depends on your margins, booking patterns, customer expectations, and whether the operational complexity is worth the cost savings.